Hi Rabbi. I remember that there was a rule regarding applying hand lotion on shabbat or yom tov that indicated that if the lotion is absorbed in the skin it is permitted to apply it on these days. Can you please clarify if I understood this properly? Are there certain creams that can or cannot be applied? What types of creams and is a normal application ok or does it have to be applied in a different way.
Thanks.
Why would it be more of an issue if medicated? Shouldn’t it be more permissible if for medical purposes?
There’s a separate prohibition for medicinal items when not absolutely necessary. This is based on the fact that in ancient times, medicines were made by grinding herbs or leaves. This would be a melachah. The Rabbis prohibited taking or using medicine on Shabbat and Yom Tov, so that you do not come to grind medicine. We don’t grind our own medicine nowadays, but the prohibition stands.
If a cream is medicated and it is clear that the usage is for this medication, it would then fall under this prohibition. To be clear, there are definitely multiple scenarios where medicine would be allowed, but without any of those exclusions, it would be prohibited.
All creams are fine except if medicated.
What is the definition of “medicated”? The FDA distinguishes between cosmetics and drugs with the latter contsining active ingredients to “treat, diagnose, or prevent a medical condition”. Nowadays most cosmetics also claim “active ingredients” and are regulated as drugs. Does using a cream with active ingredients suffice to make it medicated per the halachic definition or is it based on your intent?
Medicated is a cream that you would only use for its medicinal properties. Every cream tries to convince you that they have a special magic medicine in it. If people use it mainly as a moisturizer, then the medicated part won’t be an issue.