what does bittul torah actually mean? it cannot be that every moment not learning is bittul, so where is the line? is time spent exercising, resting, or just taking care of life considered bittul torah, or does the issur only start when a person could be learning and chooses nothing instead?
what does bittul torah actually mean, and where is the line
by moi613 | Sep 1, 2026 | Hashkafa | 4 comments
4 Comments
Submit a Comment Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Thank you Rabbi, thank you very much.
Bittul Torah does not mean that every second in which you are not looking into a sefer is an aveirah.
Limud Torah is one of the most important mitzvot we have. Without learning Torah, it is very difficult to know how to perform the other mitzvot properly, to work on our middot, or to develop a serious relationship with Hashem.
But the amount of Torah learning appropriate for each person is not identical.
The Rambam and Shulchan Aruch say that every Jewish man, whether rich or poor, young or old, even someone with a wife and children, must establish time for Torah study during the day and at night:
חייב לקבוע לו זמן לתלמוד תורה ביום ובלילה
(Hilchot Talmud Torah 1:8; Yoreh De’ah 246:1.)
Notice that the Halachah itself recognizes that a person may have a wife, children, work, financial pressures, and an entire life to take care of.
The Aruch HaShulchan says this very clearly. The simple meaning of והגית בו יומם ולילה would be to learn constantly, all day and all night, but:
דבר זה אי אפשר לכל אדם הטרוד בפרנסתו, וזהו רק ליחידים שבדור
That is simply not possible for every person who has to earn a living; it belongs to exceptional individuals. For ordinary people, he explains, the practical obligation is to establish regular times for Torah during the day and at night. (Aruch HaShulchan, Y.D. 246:7.)
One person may realistically be able to learn eighteen hours a day. Another person may have a demanding job, a spouse, children, health needs and other responsibilities and may have twenty minutes available. Those are not the same person and Hashem does not expect them to live the same schedule.
Exercising because you need to stay healthy is not bittul Torah.
Sleeping because your body needs sleep is not bittul Torah.
Working to support yourself and your family is not bittul Torah.
Spending time with your spouse and children, taking care of responsibilities, eating, resting and functioning like a normal human being are part of life.
Even recreation can has a legitimate place. A person is not a machine. If an hour of relaxing allows you to remain healthy, normal and productive, I would not turn that hour into a guilt-producing calculation of how many pages of Gemara you theoretically could have learned.
Of course, bittul Torah is a real concept. If a person has essentially removed Torah from his life, or knows that he has plenty of reasonable opportunity to learn and simply never makes it a priority, then something is missing.
But I do not think the healthy way to approach the mitzvah is to walk around with a stopwatch asking, “Was that seven minutes bittul Torah? Was that fifteen minutes?”
Each person has to look honestly at his own life and determine how much Torah learning is appropriate and realistic for him. Just as we make serious decisions about work, family, health and how many responsibilities we can reasonably carry, we should make a serious decision about how Torah fits into our day.
Then establish that learning and protect it.
If your circumstances change, change the amount.
If you can do more, wonderful. If right now you can do less, do what you can consistently and properly.
Torah learning should bring you closer to Hashem. It should not become an endless system of stress, guilt and fear that Hashem is waiting to strike you because you took a walk instead of opening another Gemara.
Do the best you reasonably can, be honest with yourself, and make sure Torah has a real and permanent place in your life.
For one person that may be most of the day.
For another, right now, it may be twenty minutes.
The mitzvah is enormous. The person’s life still matters.
Hello Rabbi,
What is considered Torah study? Just reading in order certain books or any book of Torah wisdom counts? Listening to Torah lectures, podcast about Judaism, reading Teshuvot, etc. can be counted?
All of the above