Hi Rabbi Abadi,

Thank you for your previous explanation about rabbinic laws and what happens when their original reason disappears.

I wanted to understand how this principle applies to three other cases:

Meat and fish: Chazal prohibited eating meat and fish together because of a health danger. Today, there doesn’t seem to be a medically recognized danger from combining them. Why does this prohibition remain while uncovered liquids are permitted in places where snakes are not prevalent?

Medicine on Shabbat: Chazal restricted taking medicine because of the concern of grinding herbs. Today, most medicines are manufactured industrially, and people generally don’t prepare their own medicine. Would this be considered a permanent gezerah, or could the disappearance of the original concern affect the prohibition?

Mayim Acharonim: Tosafot in Eruvin 17b explain that people no longer practiced Mayim Acharonim because melach Sedomit was not commonly found. Yet the Shulchan Aruch (OC 181:1) still calls it obligatory. If the original danger is no longer prevalent, why would the obligation remain?

In these cases, how do we determine whether the original concern was simply the reason behind a permanent enactment or a condition that limits when the prohibition applies? Is there something specific in the Gemara or Rishonim that helps us distinguish between the two?

Thank you!