Comments for kashrut.org https://kashrut.org Practicing Judaism without all the pain Thu, 29 May 2025 22:34:04 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.8.1 Comment on Trader Joes Creamy Hummus & Vegetable Wrap by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/trader-joes-creamy-hummus-vegetable-wrap/#comment-4422 Thu, 29 May 2025 22:34:04 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21694#comment-4422 Kosher. No need to worry about bugs. See https://kashrut.org/project/bugs-in-fruits-and-vegetables/ for more details as to why no need to check. In order to require checking, there must be a determination that this product commonly has bugs. This is not the case. Enjoy

]]>
Comment on questions re Shabbat by Netanel Colish https://kashrut.org/abraham-ch-2/#comment-4421 Thu, 29 May 2025 17:25:25 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21656#comment-4421 Great questions, and thank you for the answers, Rabbi Abadi!

]]>
Comment on MCT Oil by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/mct-oil/#comment-4420 Tue, 27 May 2025 07:08:41 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21658#comment-4420 Nope. They’re all fine

Besides, very few things need a hechsher. Mostly meats and certain cheeses and wines. If things did need Hechsherim, we would have real problems, because most of those are not in the least reliable.

]]>
Comment on questions re Shabbat by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/abraham-ch-2/#comment-4419 Tue, 27 May 2025 07:04:50 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21656#comment-4419 You can order on a programable delivery app to receive a Pizza on Shabbat evening or even Shabbat morning. You are not asking them specifically to cook for you on Shabbat. If they cook it late Friday afternoon, and then warm it a bit before delivery, you wouldn’t know the difference. It is not much different than going to a kosher hotel for Shabbat. They’re doing all types of things in the kitchen, but as long as you don’t need them to do it for you on Shabbat, you’re good.

With regards to the bus in an Eruv… First, I recommend everyone read the Torah Talk entry regarding Boats, Buses, Trains, and Planes. https://kashrut.org/project/can-you-ride-a-train-bus-plane-or-boat-on-shabbat/
Second in response to your questions:
Using a prepaid card works. Going on the bus is perfectly fine. passing it through the scanner is not any Melachah that I’m aware of, so it is also fine. Stopping the bus at a stop where he is not going to stop except for you… is ok, because again there is no Melachah that he is doing. Even if driving the bus is Havaarah (Like Lighting a Fire), however stopping the bus is not Mechabeh, because Mechabeh needs a Pesilah (Petilah = Wick) in order to be a Melachah.

So in summation…Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes, and Yes. Enjoy

]]>
Comment on Skipjack Tuna Fillet – Trader Joes by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/skipjack-tuna-fillet-trader-joes/#comment-4418 Tue, 27 May 2025 06:53:53 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21662#comment-4418 KOSHER

]]>
Comment on Dillon’s Limoncello by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/dillons-limoncello/#comment-4417 Tue, 27 May 2025 06:52:53 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21664#comment-4417 Nice catch. But it is fine.

]]>
Comment on wheat based glucose by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/wheat-based-glucose/#comment-4416 Fri, 09 May 2025 11:40:30 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21503#comment-4416 Thank you for your thoughtful question.

The key difference between wheat-based glucose and products like vinegar or whiskey lies in both the process and the halachic principles of ta’arovot—mixtures involving potentially problematic ingredients.

In halacha, when a non-kosher (or in this case, chametz-derived) ingredient is mixed into a food, the primary question becomes whether the original forbidden substance is still discernible in taste. This is where the concept of batel beshishim—nullification when the forbidden substance is less than 1/60th of the total—comes in.

Whiskey is often made entirely from fermented grain, possibly barley or wheat. Since the grain is the essence of the product, and the resulting alcohol is a direct product of fermentation (not distillation from non-chametz sources), we cannot assume any bitul without precise knowledge of the composition—which we rarely have from manufacturers.

Vinegar is more nuanced. If vinegar is listed as the third ingredient or later in a product, we know mathematically that its volume is small enough that any chametz content (such as from wheat-based alcohol) would be batel beshishim. But when vinegar is listed among the first two ingredients—such as in salad dressings—it may not be nullified, and we treat it more strictly.

Glucose syrup, on the other hand, is an ingredient used in extremely small quantities—especially in processed foods where it’s often one of many sweeteners or stabilizers. Even when it is derived from wheat, the wheat starch undergoes a chemical transformation that renders it unrecognizable in both substance and flavor. Furthermore, the actual proportion of any wheat that may remain is negligible—automatically falling well below the 1/60 threshold. That’s why glucose syrup, even if wheat-based, does not pose a chametz concern in practical halacha.

In summary, the halachic leniency for glucose syrup is grounded both in its chemical transformation and its minimal volume, while products like whiskey or vinegar require closer scrutiny due to their nature, source, and usage in larger concentrations.

]]>
Comment on Does an Oven Kasher itself? by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/does-an-oven-kasher-itself/#comment-4415 Wed, 30 Apr 2025 20:45:05 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21199#comment-4415 Okay, here’s my answer:

Years ago, we did a test on ovens. We took water, brought it to a full boil on the fire—steam pouring out everywhere—and then threw it into a preheated oven. What happened? The steam disappeared immediately. The water stayed hot and continued boiling, but there was no visible zeiah (steam) inside the oven.

Why? Because of how modern ovens are built. In our ovens, the steam gets burned out and dissipates into the air inside the chamber. That means there’s no halachic zeiah that would transfer taste. Yes, the Gemara talks about a tanur and a kirayim, and we often translate those as “oven,” but halachah doesn’t work by simply translating terms and transplanting halachos without understanding the differences in design and function. Our ovens are fundamentally different.

So what’s the halachic bottom line?
You can technically cook meat and milk in the same oven—even at the same time—and there’s no transfer of taste or issur. Likewise, you can cook kosher and non-kosher in the same oven simultaneously, and one does not affect the other, unless there is actual physical transfer—like liquid from one dish spilling into another. So yes, keep your eyes open. If your salmon is leaking onto the food underneath it, that’s a real issue. But absent that, there’s nothing to worry about.

As for the pizza question:
The heter isn’t noten tam lifgam. Pepperoni, for example, isn’t lifgam—it’s flavorful. But that’s not the point. When you order a vegetarian slice in a pizza shop, especially in Western countries, they won’t put meat on it. It’s not about kashrus at that point—it’s about liability. No one’s going to risk a lawsuit or bad press. So if you walk in and ask, “Is this vegetarian?” and they say yes, you can rely on that—often more confidently than in a kosher store.

In short:
• Modern ovens don’t transmit taste via steam (zeiah) because it gets destroyed inside the oven.
• Therefore, halachically, you can use a non-kosher oven for kosher food as long as there is no direct contact or liquid transfer.
• And when ordering vegetarian in a non-kosher store, you can rely on what they tell you—especially when it comes to meat—not because the pepperoni is lifgam, but because it’s not going near your slice in the first place.

]]>
Comment on Inked sourdough break kosher? by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/inked-sourdough-break-kosher/#comment-4414 Wed, 30 Apr 2025 20:31:19 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21500#comment-4414 Kosher

]]>
Comment on Bacardi Spiced Rum by Aaron Abadi https://kashrut.org/bacardi-spiced-rum/#comment-4413 Wed, 30 Apr 2025 12:38:20 +0000 https://kashrut.org/?p=21492#comment-4413 Kosher for year round. Also kosher for Pesach. Rum is made from sugar cane. Even if there’s some grain alcohol added, it won’t be enough to make it a problem on Pesach.

]]>