Q & A Board - View Post
Author:  Dan
E-mail:  not available
Date:  9/27/2004 12:48:00 AM
Subject:  Re: Tinok Shenishba
Message:  Author: Dan
E-mail: not available
Date: 8/11/2004 10:58:25 PM
Subject: re: tinok shenishba
Message: I dont quite understand USS NJ's post. First of all, by discussing the halachik status of a tinok shenishba we are not rendering definitive decision on the matter, just trying to understand the concept. Second, and more importantly, even if tinok shenishba wereto have no practical ramifications why should that stop us from discussing it? It is still a halachik idea that is part of our mesorah. This bears understanding regarldess of practical application, and any criticism of this is very misdirected

Reply: We are studying Torah, should it be like a song...
As said by Abaya...

I dont understand. Please explain what you mean?
Reply:  The Talmud talks about this very dispute where Rav Yosef says, "what's the difference, it isn't relevant today." And Abaya says that it is still Torah.

That dispute continues...

Back to the Q & A Board